How Do I Know If I Need To Replace My Roof Or Repair It?

When your roof shows signs of damage, it can sometimes be hard to know whether a repair is enough, or if the roof needs a replacement. Here’s what you should consider when deciding between a reroofing project and a roof repair.

Your Budget


roofWhen thinking about a roof replacement or repair, the cost is often the biggest consideration for homeowners. Roofing repairs cost less than a complete reroofing, but if you’re paying for many, many repairs over a few years, these will likely exceed the cost of an entire roof replacement. 

While a roof replacement is more expensive up-front, it might be much more cost-effective in the long run. Not only that, but a new roof can provide you with the assurance that what’s under your roof will be protected from the elements!


Aesthetics Vs. Structural Problems


If you’re deciding between a roof repair or roof replacement, you’ve likely noticed the roof has either deteriorated in appearance, suffered from structural damage, or both. Signs of roof damage will differ based on the kind of roofing material used, but they often have similar characteristics. 

Aesthetic damage is when the roofing material looks old and worn; often, this damage is only superficial. It can come from the growth of moss and algae on or in between the roofing materials. In these cases, cleaning or replacing shingles is the best option – your roof will still have the structural integrity to prevent leaks and keep your home protected. However, some aesthetic issues can point to structural damage. 

Structural damage is often more extensive. The shingles will have curled or cupped edges or are missing granules to create bald spots. Cracked, dented, or broken asphalt, tile or wood shingles, as well rusted metal shingles or panels, all point to the degrading of the roofing material. Sometimes, damage can be confined to small parts of the roof and only require a replacement; others can create issues that necessitate replacing the entire roof. 

The best way to make sense of your needs is to talk with a roofing contractor. They can help you understand the extent of the roof damage you notice to make the right decision for your home and budget.


What’s The Weather Like In Your Area?


roofDo you live in a part of the country susceptible to hail, ice, and torrential rains? Are tornadoes, hurricanes, and other windstorms a common occurrence? If so, you must repair any damaged roofing materials like shingles immediately to prevent roof leaks. These weather events will affect the appearance – but more importantly, the performance – of your roof. 

Replacing damaged material in that section can be relatively simple and not too costly. If you don’t have an inspection and repair right after heavy winds, though, you might find yourself replacing the roof sooner than you wanted.

Not sure if you need a repair or a replacement? Your trusted local roofing contractor will help you decide which option is best for your home – and your bottom line rather than their’s!

Share this post
Scroll to Top